Self Employed vs Limited Company: How Each Affects Your Tax Bill and Take-Home Pay

Every UK entrepreneur—whether you’re a seasoned freelancer, a side-hustling startup, or just tired of calling yourself “sole trader” at parties—hits the big decision sooner or later: What are the benefits of a self employed vs. limited company set up?

It’s not just about paperwork or looking fancy on LinkedIn. The way you structure your business changes everything—from how much tax you pay and the safety of your personal assets, to whether you’ll ever get to expense that questionable “team-building” lunch.

Choose wisely, and you could save thousands (and sleep a little better at tax time). Pick the wrong path, and you might hand more to HMRC than necessary—or worse, put your personal finances on the line.

So let’s break it down: what really changes with each route, where the tax savings are hiding, and how to pick the setup that matches your goals and your risk tolerance. No jargon, no nonsense—just the facts (with a few pro tips along the way).

Business structures explained: Self-employed, sole trader, and limited company

When you set up your business, the structure you choose isn’t just a box-ticking exercise. It shapes your tax bill, your personal liability, and even how much admin lands in your lap each year.

Self-employed and sole trader: Flexible and simple

Most new UK businesses and freelancers start out as self-employed—which usually means registering as a sole trader. This approach is:

• Quick to set up and run—just register with HMRC, pick a business name, and you’re good to go.
• Flexible—you keep full control and all profits.
• Direct—there’s no legal distinction between you and your business, so you are personally responsible for any debts or liabilities. Unlimited liability is the trade-off for simplicity.

Limited company: Separate legal entity, more protection

As your business grows, you might consider a limited company for its legal and financial advantages. This structure:

• Is registered with Companies House and requires a unique company name.
• Creates a separate legal entity—your business can enter contracts, own assets, and, crucially, is liable for its own debts.
• Shields your personal assets from business debts (unless you offer a personal guarantee).
• Involves more admin—opening a company bank account, filing annual company accounts and a confirmation statement, and formally appointing company directors (often, that’s you).

Why sole trader remains popular

Many small business owners, side-hustlers, and freelancers stick with the sole trader structure for its ease, low cost, and straightforward tax filing—at least at first. But as new business comes in and turnover, risk, or reputation needs grow, the appeal of limited liability increases.

📌 Pro Tip: If you’re not sure which type of business structure is best for your goals, speak to an accountant or business advisor early on. Switching later is possible, but a bit of advance planning can save you a lot of hassle.

How tax works for self-employed individuals

For the UK’s self-employed—whether you’re a solo consultant, graphic designer, or the brains behind a booming startup—tax isn’t just a formality. It decides your take-home pay, how you manage your business profits, and how much you might risk if things go sideways. With no legal distinction between you and your business, every decision can hit your wallet directly.

Filing your tax return

You’ll file a self assessment tax return for each tax year (ending 5 April). This is where you declare:

• Your total business profits (after expenses)
• Any other sources of personal income
• The allowable tax reliefs you’re claiming

How you’re taxed

Here’s what to expect as a self-employed person:

• You pay income tax on your business profits after deducting allowable expenses and your personal allowance.
• Class 2 National Insurance Contributions (NICs) are due at a flat weekly rate if your profits are above £6,725 per year.
• Class 4 NICs are paid as a percentage of your annual profits, with the rate increasing as your earnings rise.
• If your business income is less than £1,000 for the year, the trading allowance may apply, so you won’t owe any tax.

Tax reliefs and what’s tax-free

You can claim tax relief on a range of costs, provided they’re genuinely for business purposes:

• Travel and accommodation
• Office equipment, supplies, and software
• Business insurance
• A share of home office expenses
• Professional fees (including providers and accountants)

And yes, if you run a small side hustle, the first £1,000 can be tax-free thanks to the trading allowance.

📌 Pro Tip: As a sole trader, you’re personally liable for any business debts—meaning your personal assets are at risk if things go wrong.

How tax works for limited companies

Choosing a limited company isn’t just a stylistic upgrade—it fundamentally changes how your business is taxed, how you get paid, and what’s at risk if things go wrong. Unlike sole proprietorships, a limited company is its own legal structure, with all the paperwork (and protections) that come with it.

Separate legal structure and limited liability

Unlike a sole trader business, a limited company is a separate legal entity. That means:

• The company itself can own assets, enter contracts, and be sued or sue others in its own name.
• As director of a limited company, you benefit from limited liability—your personal assets are usually protected if the business fails, unless you’ve signed a personal guarantee.

How tax works: Corporation tax, salary, and dividends

Once your company starts trading, your tax strategy gets a bit more sophisticated. Here’s how limited company directors can pay themselves, and what that means for the taxman:

• Corporation tax is charged on your company’s taxable profits, at a rate between 19% and 25% depending on profit level, before any money is distributed to you.
• Salary is paid through PAYE—you’re technically an employee of your own company, and both income tax and National Insurance Contributions are deducted at source. Salary is a business expense, so it lowers your company’s taxable profits.
• Dividends are paid to shareholders (usually you) from profits after corporation tax has already been paid. Dividends are taxed separately, often at a lower rate than salary, and do not reduce your company’s corporation tax bill.
• Many directors opt for a mix of salary (up to the personal allowance) and dividends to keep overall tax bills as low as possible.

Filing, compliance, and business banking

Staying compliant is crucial—and more involved than with a sole trader business. Be prepared to:

• File annual accounts and a confirmation statement every year with Companies House, as well as a corporation tax return with HMRC.
• Complete all necessary company formation paperwork, update director and shareholder details as things change, and keep proper company records.
• Use a dedicated business bank account—separating company money from your own is required, and it’ll save your sanity at tax time.

Compliance matters

It pays to stay on top of your paperwork:

• HMRC and Companies House each have their own requirements and strict deadlines.
• Miss a deadline? Penalties stack up fast—and for serious breaches, you could risk your company’s standing (and your own as a director).

📌 Pro Tip: Don’t use your home address as your company’s registered office if you can avoid it. A virtual office or professional address service boosts your privacy and guarantees you won’t miss anything important from HMRC or Companies House.

Self-employed vs limited company take-home pay compared

Let’s get to the bit everyone cares about: who keeps more of their hard-earned cash? Here’s how your structure changes your tax bill, take-home pay, and options for tax efficiency.

Take-home pay at a glance

Scenario: You’ve made £50,000 profit in a year (congrats!).

	Self-Employed	Limited Company*
Income	£50,000 (business profit)	£50,000 (company profit)
Corporation Tax	N/A	-£9,500 (19%)
Salary (PAYE)	N/A	-£12,570 (uses personal allowance)
Dividends	N/A	£27,930 (post-tax profit)
Income Tax/NICs	-£7,500 tax -£3,200 NICs	-£1,950 dividend tax ~£200 NICs
Take-home (approx.)	£39,300	£41,000

*Assumes director takes a small salary + max dividends for tax efficiency. Figures rounded for simplicity; actual results depend on your exact setup and any additional income.

What’s the real difference?

• Limited company owners can pay themselves in a way that minimises NICs and leverages the dividend allowance.
• Self-employed pay income tax and NICs on nearly all profits, with no access to dividend tax rates or company-level pension contributions.
• As profits grow, the limited company structure pulls further ahead on tax savings.

What about tax reliefs and deductions?

• Both: Can claim business expenses, but companies can also deduct pension contributions, employer costs, and more.
• Self-employed: Simpler admin, but all profits above the allowance get hit with full income tax and NICs.
• Limited company: More paperwork, but more flexibility—and greater savings once profits rise above the basic rate threshold.

Which is best for you?

• If you want simplicity: Self-employed/sole trader wins.
• If you want control, protection, and more take-home pay as your profits grow: Limited company is often the smarter long-term play.

📌 Pro Tip: Always compare the full cost—including accountancy fees, Companies House filings, and your own admin time. Sometimes peace of mind is worth more than a few extra pounds.

Business expenses: What can you claim?

One of the most powerful ways to shrink your tax bill—no matter your business structure—is by claiming every allowable business expense. But what you can claim, and how you claim it, depends on whether you’re self-employed or operating a limited company. Let’s break down the essentials:

Common allowable business expenses include:

• Home office costs: You can claim a proportion of your rent, mortgage interest, utilities, and council tax if you work from home.
• Travel expenses: Business journeys (but not your daily commute), public transport, fuel, parking, and congestion charges.
• Equipment and supplies: Laptops, phones, software, stationery, office furniture—anything essential for work.
• Professional fees: Accountants, legal advice, professional subscriptions, and business insurance.

A few distinctions to remember:

• Self-employed individuals can use simplified flat-rate expenses for vehicles and home working, with all claims made via the self assessment tax return.
• Limited companies have extra options, such as claiming employer pension contributions, staff events, and relevant training costs—provided these are paid from the company’s bank account and are ‘wholly and exclusively’ for business.

Why does it matter?

• Every legitimate expense you claim directly reduces your taxable profits—so you pay less income tax (self-employed) or corporation tax (limited company).
• Careful bookkeeping and saving receipts are crucial. Good records mean less stress and more tax relief at year-end.

📌 Pro Tip: Set up a dedicated business bank account right from the start—even if you’re a sole trader. It makes expense tracking, tax returns, and HMRC checks a whole lot simpler.

Pros and cons: Key differences at a glance

If you’re weighing up “self employed vs limited company,” it helps to see the key distinctions in one place. Here’s how the two structures stack up on tax, paperwork, reputation, and risk:

Self-employed / sole trader

• Tax simplicity: Fewer forms and simpler bookkeeping—just file your annual self assessment tax return and pay income tax and National Insurance on your profits.
• Paperwork: Minimal admin, no annual accounts or confirmation statements needed.
• Business name: No official protection; someone else can register your business name as a company.
• Perceived credibility: Sometimes seen as less established by banks, clients, and providers.
• Personal assets: Unlimited liability—if your business fails, your personal assets (car, savings, home) are at risk for business debts and personal guarantees.
• Tax rates: All profits are subject to income tax rates and national insurance contributions.
• If things go wrong: You’re personally liable for all business debts.

Limited company

• Tax benefits: Potential for lower overall tax through a mix of salary and dividends, with access to more tax reliefs.
• Paperwork: More admin—must file annual accounts, a confirmation statement, and a corporation tax return.
• Business name: Legally protected; no one else can register the same name at Companies House.
• Perceived credibility: Seen as more professional and established—often preferred by bigger clients and suppliers.
• Personal assets: Limited liability means your own assets are (generally) safe if the business fails—no personal guarantee unless you specifically sign one.
• Tax rates: Company profits are taxed at the corporation tax rate; personal tax applies only to what you take out.
• If things go wrong: The company’s debts stay with the company, not with you (unless you’ve given a personal guarantee).

📌 Pro Tip: If you expect your business to grow, or want to protect your personal assets, setting up as a limited company may be worth the extra admin. For side hustles or simpler setups, self-employment could be your low-stress launchpad.

When to switch: Changing from self-employed to limited company

Switching from self-employed to limited company status is a major milestone. The right timing can mean more tax savings, better asset protection, and a more professional image. But it’s not just about filling in a Companies House form—here’s how to get it right.

When is it time to switch?

• Your profits are climbing and the numbers show you’d save money on tax as a limited company (especially if you’re consistently above the higher-rate income tax band).
• You want to limit your personal liability, especially if your business debts or risk profile are growing.
• Larger clients or providers are asking for a company, or you want to attract investment and look more credible.
• You’re planning to expand, hire staff, or bring in business partners.

How do you make the switch?

• Register a unique company name and officially form your new limited company at Companies House.
• Open a business bank account for the company—this is a must, not a nice-to-have.
• Notify HMRC that you’re stopping as a sole trader and register the company for corporation tax (and VAT if your turnover requires it).
• File your first confirmation statement and set up your accounting and payroll systems for the new structure.
• Tell your clients, providers, and insurers that you’re now trading as a limited company.

What are the admin and tax implications?

• Your company now pays corporation tax on its profits, not income tax. You pay yourself a salary and/or dividends, each with its own tax treatment.
• You’ll file annual accounts and a corporation tax return for the company, plus a self assessment tax return for yourself.
• If you switch mid-tax year, keep careful records—split self-employed and company income, and make sure tax reliefs are claimed correctly for each.

📌 Pro Tip: Don’t wait until you’ve already outgrown sole trader status—switching is easier if you plan ahead, get advice, and prepare your systems before you hit that next level of growth.

Play the long game—not just the tax game

The best entrepreneurs don’t just think about this year’s bill; they think about their five-year plan, their next big client, and that “one day” exit. Your legal structure sets you up for all of it. So whether you’re ready to switch, scale, or simply want less jargon in your inbox, it’s all about stacking the odds in your favour.

Want the latest tax wins and business know-how? Subscribe to our free newsletter. One quick signup, all the smart updates—because you’ve got better things to do than read the HMRC small print.

Frequently Asked Questions